Pollak: Senate Has Already Heard 3 Days of Witnesses and Documents in Impeachment Trial

Pollak: Senate Has Already Heard 3 Days of Witnesses and Documents in Impeachment Trial

Pollak: Senate Has Already Heard 3 Days of Witnesses and Documents in Impeachment Trial

Democrats continue to argue that the Senate impeachment trial of President Donald Trump requires further witnesses and documents. What kind of trial does not include witnesses and documents? they ask.

But the Senate has just heard witnesses and seen documents for nearly 30 hours over three days — including during a marathon opening session that was supposed to debate procedural motions, not to explore the substance of the charges against the president.

House impeachment managers have used clips from witness testimony in the public hearings that Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA) conducted in the House Intelligence Committee. Senators have been forced to sit silently as Schiff and his team have played endless video “evidence” — some of it deceptively edited to distort the witnesses’ testimony.

Most of the testimony would be excluded from an ordinary trial as hearsay evidence. But Senators have seen and heard it.

Not one of the witnesses was cross-examined in the House by the president’s lawyers, because Democrats broke with precedent and did not allow White House counsel to participate in the fact-finding phase of the investigation.

Nor did Schiff or House Judiciary Committee Chairman Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-NY) let Republicans call any new witnesses.

Now they want the Senate to allow them to do what Democrats refused to allow Republicans to do in the House.

Moreover, for all the talk of bringing in new witnesses like acting White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney, Senators have already heard from Mulvaney, because House impeachment managers have played video from the press conference in which he discussed Ukraine.

And as for documents, Democrats have repeatedly shown or described documents to the Senate that were never discussed or debated during the House Intelligence Committee inquiry.

The most striking of these documents are the phone records that Schiff obtained on Ranking Member Rep. Devin Nunes (R-CA), journalist John Solomon, presidential lawyer Rudy Giuliani, and former Giuliani associate Lev Parnas. Schiff only revealed these phone records in the House Intelligence Committee impeachment report.

House impeachment managers have made all kinds of accusations based on these records, though their accuracy is in doubt.

Worse, the records were likely obtained unlawfully, and arguably violate the president’s constitutional rights. No ordinary criminal court would ever admit them as evidence. Yet Senators have heard about them for three days.

So for all the talk of “witnesses” and “documents,” Democrats have already had plenty. Republicans and the White House have had none.

The defense does not need to call witnesses — not when prosecutors fail to prove their case.

But if Democrats get their wish — and they might — to call new witnesses, such as former National Security Advisor John Bolton, then the White House will call witnesses of its own.

It is not clear what value Bolton would provide to a case that House Democrats already say is “overwhelming.”

And after an inevitable court battle over executive privilege, one that would drag the trial out for weeks, Bolton might not be able to say much to the Senate anyway.

But the Senate would be able to compel the testimony of former vice president Joe Biden about what he has already admitted “looked bad” — namely, that the son earned a mint from Burisma while the father ran U.S. Ukraine policy.

And the White House would invoke the president’s Sixth Amendment right to cross-examine his accuser — the elusive “whistleblower,” whom Democrats hid.

Arguably, the public has a right to know who started this, and why.

Joel B. Pollak is Senior Editor-at-Large at Breitbart News. He earned an A.B. in Social Studies and Environmental Science and Public Policy from Harvard College, and a J.D. from Harvard Law School. He is a winner of the 2018 Robert Novak Journalism Alumni Fellowship. He is also the co-author of How Trump Won: The Inside Story of a Revolution, which is available from Regnery. Follow him on Twitter at @joelpollak.

Read More


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

More News

‘Never Trumper’ Super PAC Expenditures Going to Consultants

‘Never Trumper’ Super PAC Expenditures Going to Consultants

The majority of the money spent in the first four months of operations by The Lincoln Project, a Super PAC founded by George Conway and other “Never Trumpers,” has been paid to consultants affiliated with the project. From its inception in November 2019 until February 21, 2020, The Lincoln Project has reported $180,624 in expenditures,… … Read More

New York City Library Hosts Chinese Propaganda Exhibit on Tibet

New York City Library Hosts Chinese Propaganda Exhibit on Tibet

The Elmhurst branch of the Queens Public Library in New York City announced on Friday that it would take down a Chinese government exhibit falsely depicting children in Tibet as happily learning the Tibetan language and living freely – a far cry from the repressive reality Beijing has imposed on the region. New York’s local… … Read More

Rob Reiner Accuses Trump of Treason: He’s ‘Siding With Russia’

Rob Reiner Accuses Trump of Treason: He’s ‘Siding With Russia’

Left-wing filmmaker Rob Reiner is once again accusing President Donald Trump of treason, a federal offense that carries a possible death sentence. The Princess Bride director made his latest accusation in a tweet late Friday, claiming that President Trump is “siding with Russia” over the U.S. Rob Reiner has repeatedly accused President Trump of committing crimes,… … Read More


© Copyright 2020 | American Priority | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy