Fact Check: Mitt Romney Misquotes Dershowitz In Speech on Convicting Trump

Fact Check: Mitt Romney Misquotes Dershowitz In Speech on Convicting Trump

Fact Check: Mitt Romney Misquotes Dershowitz In Speech on Convicting Trump

AP Photo/Rick Bowmer, File

CLAIM: The president’s lawyers said “there could be no impeachment without a statutory crime.”

VERDICT: FALSE. That is the opposite of what the president’s lawyers argued before the Senate.

Sen. Mitt Romney (R-UT) misquoted the White House counsel’s argument in his speech in the Senate Wednesday explaining why he would vote to remove President Donald Trump from office.

Romney said that one of the president’s defenses was that “there could be no impeachment without a statutory crime.”

That is not, however, what the White House counsel argued.

Alan Dershowitz presented the constitutional arguments against impeachment. He argued that a president had to commit “criminal-like” behavior even if there had been no statutory crime.

Specifically, Dershowitz said that the Constitution required “criminal-like conduct akin to treason and bribery.”

Dershowitz then added the exact opposite of what Romney claimed he said: “There need not be, in my view, conclusive evidence of a technical crime that would necessarily result in a criminal conviction.”

U.S. Senate

Compare those two statements again:

Romney: “The president’s team claimed ‘there could be no impeachment without a statutory crime.’”

Dershowitz: “There need not be, in my view, conclusive evidence of a technical crime that would necessarily result in a criminal conviction.”

The White House did point out that no president had ever been impeached before without any crime or even any statutory violation being alleged in the articles of impeachment, but the president’s lawyers did not make the argument Romney claimed.

Either Romney was not paying attention, or he simply constructed a “straw man” to justify a decision he had made for other, personal or political, reasons.

Romney said that the idea that “the lack of a codified and comprehensive list of all the outrageous acts that a president might conceivably commit renders Congress powerless to remove such a president defies reason.”

No one in the White House team of lawyers ever made such an argument.

Romney’s misquote continues a pattern among the president’s detractors. Lead House impeachment manager Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA) also repeatedly distorted and lied about what Dershowitz said.

Romney’s decision to vote to convict on the first article of impeachment, alleging “abuse of power” (he reportedly decided not to vote for the second, alleging “obstruction of justice”) will make at least that part of the vote to remove Trump from office a bipartisan one, even if it fails the two-thirds threshold.

Joel B. Pollak is Senior Editor-at-Large at Breitbart News. He earned an A.B. in Social Studies and Environmental Science and Public Policy from Harvard College, and a J.D. from Harvard Law School. He is a winner of the 2018 Robert Novak Journalism Alumni Fellowship. He is also the co-author of How Trump Won: The Inside Story of a Revolution, which is available from Regnery. Follow him on Twitter at @joelpollak.

Read More

Share:

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

More News

***Live Updates*** George Floyd Protests Continue

***Live Updates*** George Floyd Protests Continue

George Floyd Protests Continue on Saturday. Stay tuned to Breitbart News for live updates. All times eastern. — 7:59 PM: Paul Ryan and John Boehner won’t say if they’ll vote for Trump in November. George W. Bush has already decided he won’t support him, say those familiar with his thinking. https://t.co/V7wUZB9kLS — Aman Batheja (@amanbatheja) June… … Read More

Mayor Frey Asks Trump for Help After Rioters Cause Millions in Damage

Mayor Frey Asks Trump for Help After Rioters Cause Millions in Damage

Mayor Jacob Frey (D) is seeking federal aid to help Minneapolis recover from the protests and riots that have wrecked the area. “With at least $55 million in estimated damage and far more to come, Minneapolis will need state and federal aid as it attempts to rebuild hundreds of structures after the riots following George… … Read More

Bernie Sanders’ Adviser: D-Day Largest Antifa Operation in History

Bernie Sanders’ Adviser: D-Day Largest Antifa Operation in History

Matt Duss, foreign policy adviser to Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), commemorated the 76th anniversary of D-Day by describing it as the “largest Antifa operation in history.” Duss seemingly attempted to legitimize Antifa, the so-called anti-fascist group behind much of the political violence erupting at protests across U.S. cities, by equating it to the courageous Allied… … Read More

FOLLOW

© Copyright 2020 | American Priority | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy